Wednesday 18 September 2019

Inverleith at Play



I have just given a talk to the AGM of the Inverleith Society. It does not pretend to be an academic paper - more at pub quiz level - but it does contain some interesting snippets of information I found while searching for material. Many thanks to the Scottish and Edinburgh section of the Edinburgh Public Library for assistance; and to the Society for inviting me.

*   *   *   *   *

In the summer of 1973 we arrived in Edinburgh. I could not pronounce Penicuik; I had never heard of Inverleith. Then sometime in October the list of the coming Saturday’s rugby fixtures was posted on the board. There it was: GHH – JA2s – Inverleith. A helpful colleague explained, “Oh that’s just across Kinnear Road. You change at home.” He did not explain it was an away match, so I changed as well. But my embarrassment as I shivered in the freezing wind is another story.

So from my first months in Edinburgh I associated Inverleith with rugger. In fact I was already acquainted with a fictional rugby match, between Scotland and Australia, which begins “Castle Gay” by John Buchan. The hero scores the winning try: “He was still dazed and panting when a minute later the whistle blew, and a noise like the Last Trump told him that by a single point he had won the match for his country. There was a long table below the Grand Stand, a table reserved for the Press. On it might have been observed a wild figure with red hair dancing a war dance of triumph. Presently the table collapsed under him, and the rending of timber and the recriminations of journalists were added to the apocalyptic din”.

In fact this book was published just after Rugby Internationals had moved from Inverleith to Murrayfield; but I reckon that while Buchan was conceiving his story he had Inverleith in mind. The SRU bought the ground in 1897 for £3,800. International matches were held there from 1899 till 1925. There were many notable incidents:

1899 against Ireland: “Moneypenny kicked the ball past the full back, over the line, and was running on to touch down when he was tackled from behind and brought down” – Scotland converted the resultant penalty.

Some of the incidents show how the game remains the same. In 1903 against Wales “conditions were appalling. A fierce gale of wind and blinding rain coming from the south west.” Others, though, are interesting evidence of changes, In 1905 New Zealand played with seven forwards who packed down 2-3-2. There was one “roving forward”. There were no substitutes in those days, of course. In 1899 against Wales “Neilson had his nose fractured and some of the fluency amongst the backs vanished”. I’m not surprised. In 1907 against Ireland “MacLear handed off his man so severely as to knock him out and he spent a while recovering on the straw on the touchline.”

There is a pleasant story from 1911: “The Scottish captain on that day later gave his cap to a tribal chief in the Sudan, who wore it on state occasions instead of his fez.”

I was astonished I my researches to discover that one G Harris refereed the very first French match in 1910. I can identify with his problems. “They were all inclined to get offside and tackle opponents who did not have the ball; one claimed a mark from a kick behind him. But the referee allowed them considerable latitude to keep the game flowing”.

It sounds as though that referee could have handled the JA3s quite well. I only once performed in front of an international crowd. There were so many matches one Saturday that we were dispatched to play in Inverleith Park, against some appropriately lowly Stewart’s Melville side. As the game wore on I became aware that our opponents had considerable support, who were not inhibited about commenting on my refereeing. They were all wearing bobble hats in what appeared to be Stewart’s Melville colours. I only gradually realised that their helpful advice was all in Welsh accents. Their team was playing at Murrayfield that afternoon.

I will end my Rugby reminiscences by mentioning a different Welsh match, in 1901. “The match was postponed because of the death of Queen Victoria, and as a mark of respect the spectators were predominantly in black.”

Of course the game most closely associated with Scotland must be golf. The following extract from “The Expedition of Humphrey Clinker” was written in 1771. It refers to Bruntsfield not to Inverleith, but the quotation takes us back before Inverleith was part of Edinburgh at all.
“I was shown one particular set of golfers, the youngest of whom was turned fourscore. They were all gentlemen of independent fortunes who had amused themselves with this pastime for the best part of a century, without ever having felt the least alarm from sickness or disgust, and they never went to bed without having each the best part of a gallon of claret.”

In those days Inverleith was all the Rocheid estate. Henry Cockburn’s “Memorials” give us a wonderful picture of one of that family.
“Except Mrs Siddons in some of her displays or magnificent royalty, no one could sit down like the lady of Inverleith. She would sail like a ship from Tarshish, gorgeous in velvet or rustling in silk, and done up in all the accompaniments of fan, ear rings and finger rings, falling sleeves, scent bottle, embroidered bag, hoop and train – all superb, yet all in purest taste; and managing all this seemingly heavy rigging, with as much ease as a full blown swan does its plumage, she would take possession of the centre of a large sofa, and at the same moment, without the slightest visible exertion, would cover the whole of it with her bravery, the graceful folds seeming to lay themselves over it like summer waves. The descent from her carriage too, where she sat like a nautilus in its shell, was a display which no one in these days could accomplish or even fancy. The mulberry coloured coach, spacious but apparently not too large for what it carried, - though she alone was in it; the handsome jolly coachman and his splendid hammercloth loaded with lace; the two respectful liveried footmen, one on each side of the richly carpeted step; these were lost sight of amidst the slow majesty with which the lady came down and touched the earth. She presided, in this imperial style, over her son’s excellent dinners, with great sense and spirit, to the very last day almost of a prolonged life.”

This passage reminds us that the word “play” encompasses far more than organised games. Here is the first verse of a song that was going round London in the 1690s that challenges Scotland’s reputation as a place of dour, puritanical rectitude:

                ’Twas within a furlong of Edinburgh town
                In the rosy time of year when the grass was down;
                Bonny Jocky blithe and gay said to Jenny making hay,
                Let’s sit a little (dear) and prattle, ‘tis a sultry day.
                He long had courted the black-brown maid,
                But Jockey was a wag and would ne’er consent to wed,
                Which made her Pish and Pooh, and cry out it will not do,
                I cannot, cannot, cannot, wonnot, wonnot buckle to.

I doubt if organised games were played on the banks of the Water of Leith in past centuries, either. I found the following information in “Sketch of St Bernard’s”, published in 1907 by John Turnbull Smith.

“The only playground or public park that the boys of the village [Stockbridge] had in old days was a piece of waste ground on the banks of the Water of Leith called “The Whins”. The ground is now occupied by ‘The Colony’.”

By a happy chance we know quite a lot about the games played there by boys and girls once the Colonies had been built, thanks to some excellent oral history. Here old people remember their childhood in the early Twentieth century:
“We played kick-the-can. Someone used to kick the can as far as they could and the rest ran away and hid... The girls would play peevers on the pavement…. We used to make tents out of old blankets and carpet on the pavement. You put sticks in the cobbles and tied strings on an old blanket…I used to sit and crochet these balls of coloured wool. We used to go and buy them with our pocket money and sit on the steps and crochet. We were easy pleased in those days, eh? We played among the bushes and slid down the hills. We took dolls and played houses…One of our favourite games in the winter was getting trays from my mother and going along the path in Rocheid Park where there was a slope down to the Water of Leith, and when the snow was on the ground it was super, a super slide, we used to slide right down…Skipping-ropes, oh that was a great favourite…We played bowls, and cuddies loups – one would lean against the garden paling and bend down and others would jump on top and when one fell off he would join the one that was bending down and it eventually all collapsed…Then Bella McBain, she was really good at diabolo - the only one in the Colonies who could do it… And fire cans; that had a craze for a while. You’d get an old syrup tin, get two holes in it and put wire as a handle then you put paper and sticks and sometimes a bit coal in it and you lit it and you hurled it round and round till it was red hot…We used to play dodge. You had sides and you shouted your numbers and then you threw a ball at them…Our fathers and mothers used to come out to play with us. They’d come out and hold the skipping ropes for us, play rounders, or dodgy with us. Not just our family, it was a right wee community down here…When Inverleith Pond was frozen the Reid’s had ice skates and we’d get a shot of them. When we had snow we’d build a fort at the bottom of the street and have snow fights. They’d come from other streets, and VOOM!”

I get the impression from the Evening News that the great age of Inverleith Park was in the twenty years before the First World War. It was laid out in 1890. Only two years  later we read: “The avenues of trees are without exception in full leaf and look remarkably well, as if they had been planted for years. The tree guards which surround them were invented by Mr MacLeod and are of a special design.” The Public Parks Committee of the Council frequently discussed the facilities at the Park. We have already heard about skating at the pond. Well, in 1897 the City Superintendent of Works was advertising for the right sort of gardener: “Tender for Clay Puddle Works”. In 1902 there was a note in the Evening News – “Edinburgh skaters will be able to practice their art in the pond at Inverleith Park this evening, the surface having been cleared of snow this afternoon”

Not everything went smoothly, mind you. Leaving aside the unfortunate case of the cricketer who dropped dead in 1903, there was a sad tragedy in 1905 when a four-year old drowned in the pond. His father took the Council to court, but the Sheriff agreed with the Council’s advocate that the arrangements were the same as at every other park in the country. It was not until the 1950s that work was put in hand to make the water much shallower, so as to remove – or at least reduce – the risk of drowning.

A plan for a ride, with a track for horses right round the Park, was considered but not taken up. However, in 1898 we read advertisements for a gardener who can make a bowling green. Then in 1900 there was a triumphant announcement: “The Public Works Committee of Edinburgh Town Council had before them today proposals for the provision at Inverleith Park of a cloakroom for skaters, store room for model yachts, a football pavilion and a covered space for the storage of goal posts, ladies lavatory etc. It is proposed to convert the farm buildings and the cottage at the east end of the pond to these purposes.”

The park and its facilities came in very useful a couple of years later in June 1902, there were The Scots Children’s Sports, Coronation Festivities. Not all Scots children were here, you understand. Inverleith Park hosted children from Broughton, Canonmills, Dean, Flora Stevenson, St Bernard’s and Stockbridge Primary Schools.  There was another big children’s sports event – the Interpark Sports – in 1939. The programme included touch rugby, Danish Handball, and Girls Open Tenniquoits.

Skaters in winter. Model yacht enthusiasts in summer. In June 1930 the “Scotsman” had a fine photo (along with photos of the first day at Ascot) of model yachts on Inverleith Pond. The size of some of the craft is striking. It is hard to tell from a photo, but I would put some of the masts at four or five feet. In 1924 there is a note of the racing for the McLennan trophy. The final was won by J.S.Kelly’s “Peggy”, with G McDonald’s “Maggie” coming second. In 1966 permission was given for the model yachts to have use of the pond one Sunday in each month. In 1981 the first Scottish Model Yacht Racing Championship was held here.

There were frequent soccer matches – Cockenzie Star, Granton Oakvale, Leith Victoria. In fact in the 1930s there was a request for more soccer pitches, but this was rejected on the grounds that this could only be achieved by making the pitches slightly too small.  But, as I mentioned earlier, “play” does not only mean organised, or disorganised games. There were also many brass band concerts. For example, the Edinburgh and Leith Postal Band: such composers as Ellenberg, Volti, Waldteufel, Myddleton. I was struck, though, by several references to riots on these occasions. 1906 seems to have been a turbulent year.  On the 30th of June some 40 youths started throwing stones, bottles and turf to the danger of passers by. Later that year we hear of a similar gang using “filthy language” and annoying people listening to the band. Later that summer some rioters appeared before Sheriff Guy, who said that “this had been nothing short of an attempt by the mob to rule the police”.

So with relief, perhaps we can conclude by leaving Inverleith and crossing the bridge to Canonmills, as I am sure many people from this part of town did in the late nineteenth century, to visit the Great Sea Serpent.

By a happy chance when that excellent book by James Grant, “Old and New Edinburgh” was written in 1880, the Royal Patent Gymnasium was part of new Edinburgh. While you look at the photocopy I will read what Grant had to say:

“In this quarter we find the Patent Royal Gymnasium. Few visitors leave the city without seeing it. It was constructed by Mr Cox of Gorgie House for the purpose of affording healthful and exhilarating recreation. In April 1865 it was opened by the provosts, magistrates and councillors of Edinburgh and Leith. Here was a vast rotating boat, 471 feet in circumference, seated for 600 rowers; a giant see-saw named “Chang”, 100 feet long and seven feet broad, supported on an axle and capable of containing 200 persons, alternately elevating them to a height of fifty feet and then sinking almost to the ground; a velocipede paddle merry-go-round, 160 feet in circumference, seated for 600 persons who propel the machine by sitting astride the rim and pushing their feet against the ground; a self-adjusting trapeze, enabling gymnasts to swing by the hands 130 feet; a compound pendulum swing capable of holding 100 persons, kept in motion by their own exertions.
Here too are a vast number of climbing and vaulting poles. Rotary ladders, stilts, spring-boards, quoits, balls, bowls and little boats and canoes on ponds, propelled by novel and amusing methods. In winter the ground is prepared for skaters, and when lighted up at night by hundreds of lights, the scene, with its musical accessories, is one of wonderful brightness, gaiety, colour and incessant motion.”

One young man who enjoyed it was Robert Louis Stevenson. He wrote that he particularly liked the café. I shall end with his comment: “Here was advertised café au lait, with or without milk”



Sunday 8 September 2019

Creationtide appeal in aid of Trees for Life


Good morning. It’s September. This is the month when we celebrate creation. I can’t think of a better way of trying to keep the first great commandment, to love God, than honouring creation.

This year our theme for Creationtide is trees. Trees are wonderful. They soak up carbon; they store carbon; they can be used to replace concrete and steel and plastic in all sorts of applications (there are even some timber skyscrapers being built nowadays); they provide habitats for all sorts of creatures.

This is Charity Sunday. There are lots of good tree charities. We chose one. Our plan is to plant at least 200 trees with Trees for Life. 200 goes well with our bicentenary. If everyone who comes to church today makes a donation we should meet our target easily. Donations during the summer – mostly from visitors during the week – have got us off to a good start. You can see the effect on the display on the north wall. By the end of the month let us have at least 200.

If you would like to give an exact number of trees, think in terms of a multiple of six. The trees are six pounds each. But all donations large or small will be most welcome.

You should have got a Charity Sunday envelope in front of you. If you can fill it straight away, just put it in the collection now. But any time in the next couple of weeks will do fine.

Climate change is harming the poor and disadvantaged all across the world. Just at the moment I can’t think of a better way of keeping the second great commandment, to love our neighbour, than doing something like this to help mitigate the effects of climate change.



To find out more about Trees for Life do visit their web-site:
https://treesforlife.org.uk/

Tuesday 18 June 2019

Lake District Landscapes

One day in the late 1960s I was walking on the Coniston fells with  group from the Fell and Rock Club. I was not a member in those days, but they were friendly as always. I remember saying to someone that I would dearly love to paint the fells. I wasn't "good at" drawing or at school Art. But on reaching adulthood I seem to have done more and more painting.

So if you can drop in to The Ambleside Parish Centre on June 21st, 22nd or 23rd you will see what I do.

If I can get out with my easel that is one of my favourite days out.


On this occasion (at the head of Mosedale) there was a layer of heavy cloud at about 2400 feet, which impaired the prospect of the Scafells. Once I got home I added the tops, using a sketch made a couple of years previously.

Better weather helps! here is one of my recent plein aire paintings.


The Buttermere valley was so beautiful on that day in May that I was almost in a trance. There was a cuckoo all the time too. Even though the painting is a fairly accurate representation of the scene it is not a copy. A big tree on the left has been removed, so as to allow Fleetwith Pike to be seen; and the light on the lake and on the beck was changing constantly - not to mention the sky.

My sketching easel is about 40 years old; battered but serviceable. The oldest picture in the exhibition is one I did of Greenburn Beck over twenty years ago. I had walked with my gear from Coniston and was standing on a rock that jutted out. I was less prepared in those days, I recall, for the sun moving and altering the lighting completely.



A more recent piece of kit is a small pochade box. This can be carried in the rucksack further than a leggy easel.



Since I retired I have more time for painting at home, and I am very lucky to have a room in the roof I can use for painting. Most of my paintings now are made at home. This one is Goats Water.



This one is Coniston Old Man, with Levers Water in the foreground. You can see that I sometimes enjoy heightening the colour. But I hope something of the atmosphere of the place is preserved.


I always work from sketches - usually pen these days. I always have a pocket sketch-book; or a larger one if I am on my own and not going to hold up the party. I have nothing at all against painting from photos; I just do not find I can do it. Here are two separate views of the main ridge of the Coniston fells, from sketches made years apart, though the paintings are both recent.


Green is notoriously tricky for landscape painters; but this is what it is like on a fine summer's day when one stops for a sandwich on Great Carrs..


This one is from near the top of Prison Band.

There are a few people whose opinions of my paintings I take very seriously.One is a former pupil, now quite well known in the Edinburgh art world. He commented after my last exhibition that I was too often using small brushes in small paintings. Well, here is a large painting of Harrison Stickle, done almost entirely with rags.



I am astonished to find that this show will have 58 paintings altogether. Despite my friend's exhortation to paint large and free I have also been experimenting with small paintings (unframed so that you can display them as you please). They are all done from sketches. The aim, as always, is to get some of the atmosphere of a place down in paint.


If you can drop in this weekend that will be great. I expect the photos flatter the paintings.

Thursday 6 June 2019

Junior History Exams


Junior History Exams

There is some discussion going on just now about what sort of exams should be set to junior pupils in the years before GCSE.

For what it is worth, this is what we did. Many teachers in other subjects regarded this with deep suspicion, but none of the history teachers did (except that it took a long time to mark).

By “Juniors” I mean the three years before the GCSE course started. In Scotland we call this P7, S1 and S2. Is this Y7, Y8 and Y9 in England?

Part 1: Facts test on the history we had studied during the year.
P7: Tested on a specific list of facts (a double side of A4) given out about 10 days in advance.
S1: A carefully selected set of pages (about 20) in the text book.
S2: Rather more pages in what was a more advanced text-book.
This enabled hard-working pupils to do well – good for self-esteem. Pupils who reckoned they were “less good at history” (whatever that means) could surprise themselves by doing well. Chancers had nowhere to hide. With luck most of them ended the year knowing some bits of history that were worth knowing.

Part 2: Essay
But (and this was the bit some members of other departments could not understand) the titles were given out in advance. In fact, as you will all realise, this meant that no one who could have written a good essay could be caught out by unexpected titles, and no chancer would benefit from an essay on the one topic he knew about a bit. Everyone could (and almost all did) apply the methods of essay writing we had worked on during the year, and work hard at preparing the best essay they could.
The fact that they still had to write it from memory, and against the clock, gave them useful practice in the exam situation.

Part 3. Sources
I can’t now remember exactly what questions we set. But the principle was to set material (on the period we had been studying) that required the minimum of background knowledge beyond the general, and which obliged them to read carefully and to think, before writing their answers.

Part 4: Optional
A pet hate of mine was characters who sat twiddling their thumbs (or being a nuisance) after the exam had finished, so there was some sort of open-ended task that was fun enough to get on with, for those who finished early.

Marking:  No marks, grades or orders
I suppose this was the radical bit. Over the years as Head of Department I had arguments with heads and deputy heads which I sometimes lost for a year or two, but always ended up winning in the end. (My last Headmaster was a history teacher and a lot younger than me, which made it easier).
But every pupil would have an A4 comment sheet, divided into sections (Effort – Writing – I cant remember now – which had to be filled in. You can see why we found the marking harder work than the tick-the-box merchants in other subjects.

Summary
I look back at this and think “Yes. It worked all right”. We may not have gone on to get outstanding GCSE results (we didn’t) but all our juniors, even the ones who took the subject no further, had a petty useful education every exam season.